Skip to content
Daily gaming industry news.
Follow on social
Gaming Trends, One Bite at a Time
Gaming Trends, One Bite at a Time
Events

🍪 Game Cookies’ Game Awards Ballot: Our Picks, Our Doubts, and the Nomination We Would Change

Hello there, trophy polishers and players already rehearsing their disagreement with an envelope. Today we are talking about The Game Awards, the games we…

25 min read
Kiki reviews her awards ballot with Chip at a purple-lit gaming awards ceremony.

Hello there, trophy polishers and players already rehearsing their disagreement with an envelope. Today we are talking about The Game Awards, the games we would reward, and the annual ceremony in which enjoying something somehow becomes a team sport.

We’re leaving GTA VI out of our personal picks in every category because we haven’t played it yet. It remains among the official nominees, and we still predict it will win GOTY.

Control Resonant makes our strongest balanced case, Phantom Blade Zero deserves serious consideration, and we would have put Crimson Desert on the shortlist ahead of 007 First Light.

But the awards have thirty categories. A game can disappoint us in its writing and still deserve recognition for its sound. A remake can be beautifully made without becoming our game of the year. The smaller categories deserve arguments of their own, not the same GOTY vote repeated thirty times.

Below are all thirty official categories and their nominees, with our choices and the arguments still dividing us.

Game of the Year

Nominees: 007 First Light; Control Resonant; Grand Theft Auto VI; Phantom Blade Zero; Resident Evil Requiem; The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time.

Our prediction: GTA VI will win Game of the Year.

We see this award going to GTA VI, no matter how we would vote. Among the games we are evaluating, Control Resonant makes our strongest balanced case.

GTA VI qualifies: its November 19 release falls before the November 20 cutoff. We support its inclusion. Keighley also told Variety that the calendar was not changed for GTA. Our judgment of the game itself comes after we play it.

Control Resonant gives us the most convincing balance of story and enjoyable gameplay. The combat does become familiar, especially when a favorite ability solves too many encounters. That is a real weakness in an otherwise strong overall contender.

Phantom Blade Zero also deserves to be here. We may be tired of familiar challenging-action conventions, but its identity and combat still make an argument. Its rough PC start counts against it; later improvements do not erase what early buyers experienced.

Resident Evil Requiem is entertaining, but nostalgia cannot fix the writing gaps that bothered us. Grace’s repeated hesitant delivery did not work for us either.

Ocarina of Time remains our favorite game of all time. We wanted this remake to attempt more. A reinvention such as Resident Evil 2 can earn a fresh claim to GOTY; a faithful reconstruction must be judged on what this team added, not simply on what the original achieved. Our full review explains that disappointment.

007 First Light was entertaining enough, but its conventional approach did not persuade us that it belonged here ahead of Crimson Desert. Crimson’s story and pacing have problems too. Its technical ambition makes the omission harder to accept.

🦊 Kiki: “Crimson Desert has problems. So does practically everything on this list. The question is which problems come attached to something exciting enough to deserve the argument. I would rather wrestle with an ambitious game than finish a perfectly respectable one and struggle to remember what made it special.

“And Ocarina, darling, you already have my heart. You do not get every future trophy as part of the arrangement. I want a remake to give me a reason to return beyond checking whether my childhood now has better lighting. Resident Evil 2 understood the assignment. Affection should raise our expectations, not do the judging for us.”

🍪 Chip: Chip floats between an old heart-shaped Ocarina badge and a blank trophy, carefully keeping them on separate shelves.

Best Game Direction

Nominees: Control Resonant; Grand Theft Auto VI; Phantom Blade Zero; Pragmata; Resident Evil Requiem.

Our proposed pick: Pragmata. Combining a shooting encounter with a puzzle that has to be solved during the fight is a risky idea. It could easily make both activities worse. Pragmata’s hacking-and-shooting design makes them depend on each other instead: Diana opens the opportunity, Hugh uses it, and the player has to manage both.

The quieter material matters too. Diana’s drawings and interactions in the Shelter build attachment outside the usual upgrade-and-reward cycle. The relationship becomes part of why the action matters.

Control and Phantom Blade offer strong execution, and Requiem’s contrasting protagonists give it an argument. Pragmata gets our proposal because its central design takes a more unusual risk and connects it to the characters.

🦊 Kiki: “Pragmata interests me because ‘solve a puzzle while something tries to kill you’ sounds like an excellent way to ruin two perfectly good activities. Making that combination work is a direction worth rewarding. Then Diana hands over a drawing, and suddenly the little person helping you survive matters beyond her usefulness in a fight.

“That is the ambition I want from this category: an idea with consequences for how I play and why I care. I am happy to admire a gorgeous corridor, but sooner or later somebody has to give me a reason to walk down it. Preferably one more interesting than finding the next gorgeous corridor.”

🍪 Chip: Chip hovers over a complicated tactical diagram, then carefully pins a small crayon drawing in its center.

Best Narrative

Nominees: 007 First Light; Control Resonant; Grand Theft Auto VI; Resident Evil Requiem; The Blood of Dawnwalker.

Close call: Control Resonant or The Blood of Dawnwalker. Control’s story is already one of our reasons for backing it overall. Its developments are harder to anticipate, while Requiem too often falls back on familiar Resident Evil story patterns. The player argument for Dawnwalker is more specific than “another dark RPG”: people praise its character writing and substantial side stories. In a direct discussion of the narrative nominees, Control supporters point to the protagonist’s trauma and the twists, while Dawnwalker supporters emphasize its characters and writing.

That is the comparison worth having. Control’s concentrated character story or Dawnwalker’s wider web of people and consequences? Our problems with Requiem’s writing keep it behind both.

Best Art Direction

Nominees: Control Resonant; Grand Theft Auto VI; Mouse: P.I. For Hire; Phantom Blade Zero; The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time.

Our proposed pick: Control Resonant. Its framing and composition give it an artistic identity beyond expensive scenery. The images feel deliberately arranged to make the world unsettling, rather than simply to demonstrate what the hardware can render.

Mouse: P.I. For Hire and Phantom Blade Zero make strong cases through very different visual styles. Ocarina’s reconstruction can be beautiful too, but we would give the advantage to new visual expression over the careful recreation of an established one. That puts Control first for us.

Best Score and Music

Nominees: Ace Combat 8: Wings of Theve; Grand Theft Auto VI; Mixtape; Phantom Blade Zero; The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time.

Our pick: Ace Combat 8: Wings of Theve. We loved the game, especially the music. Its best tracks are already in our playlist. The music helps carry the action, then stays with us after the mission ends. These are tracks we kept listening to after putting the controller down, and it is the easiest choice on our ballot.

The campaign from Ace Combat players makes clear how much the soundtrack means to that audience too. Phantom Blade, Mixtape, and Ocarina offer different musical strengths, but Ace Combat gets our vote.

🦊 Kiki: “Ace Combat already won the argument in this house. We loved playing it, and the music came home with us. Those tracks are in our playlist because we actually want to hear them again, not because an awards campaign instructed us to appreciate the production values.

“That is what makes this such an easy vote. The score gives the action more feeling, then survives perfectly well after the mission ends. A soundtrack that gets voluntary repeat plays has done something right. Congratulations to the composers: the planes have landed, but apparently our ears are still on deployment.”

🍪 Chip: Chip floats beside the playlist, reaches toward another album, then quietly taps replay on Ace Combat.

Best Audio Design

Nominees: Ace Combat 8: Wings of Theve; Control Resonant; Grand Theft Auto VI; Resident Evil Requiem; Star Wars: Galactic Racer.

Close call: Resident Evil Requiem, Ace Combat 8, or Star Wars: Galactic Racer. Requiem remains our initial choice, with strong competing cases for Ace Combat and Galactic Racer. Galactic Racer players describe audio cues clear enough to follow the action with the HUD off. The same discussion includes praise for Ace Combat’s aircraft sounds and how they reinforce the action.

Best Performance

Nominees: Angela Sant’Albano, Resident Evil Requiem; Liam McIntyre, Marvel’s Wolverine; Manni L. Perez, Grand Theft Auto VI; Patrick Gibson, 007 First Light; Rahul Kohli, Saros.

No final pick yet. Grace’s delivery did not convince us, so Angela Sant’Albano would not be our automatic choice. Our GTA VI exclusion also applies to Manni L. Perez’s performance. Liam McIntyre, Patrick Gibson, and Rahul Kohli are the alternatives for our final vote.

Games for Impact

Nominees: Big Walk; Cairn; Forever Ago; Life is Strange: Reunion; lily’s world XD; Mixtape.

Looking at this year’s nominees, we don’t have a winner, and honestly, we don’t care enough about this category to pick one. We’d rather see The Game Awards remove it.

Innovation in Accessibility

Nominees: Assassin’s Creed Black Flag Resynced; Forza Horizon 6; Gears of War: E-Day; Marvel’s Wolverine; Rhythm Heaven Groove.

Our proposed pick: Forza Horizon 6. One of the most useful player accounts comes from a person with visual difficulties who describes being able to adjust troublesome effects and use the radar’s proximity warnings. That gives us an actual use case behind the nomination.

Assassin’s Creed, Gears, Wolverine, and Rhythm Heaven deserve comparison across different access needs. Forza is a supported starting choice, with feedback from players using those features carrying more weight for us than the number of settings in a menu.

🦊 Kiki: “That Forza player’s account is the part I care about. They can adjust the effects that cause trouble and use a warning they can actually see. There is a person getting to enjoy a race because somebody thought about how they would play it.

“Give me more of that. Let people adjust the information, inputs, and presentation until the challenge is the race itself. A menu with fifty options is lovely, but the useful result is the person who can finally join their friends. I would like the accessibility award to arrive with fewer marketing adjectives and more people holding controllers.”

🍪 Chip: Chip hovers beside a tiny racing display, enlarges its warning indicator, and slides a controller toward an empty chair.

Best Ongoing

Nominees: Arc Raiders; Final Fantasy XIV; Fortnite; No Man’s Sky; The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt.

Our proposed pick: No Man’s Sky. Its players’ nomination discussion makes the case for a game that continues to earn their attention through ongoing development. That is the reason to back it, rather than simply replaying the story of its original launch.

The shortlist is also worth questioning. Warframe appears under Community Support but not Ongoing, and Minecraft is absent too. Those omissions make the category feel narrower than the range of games people keep returning to. Among the nominees, No Man’s Sky remains our proposed vote.

Best Community Support

Nominees: Crimson Desert; Helldivers 2; No Man’s Sky; The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt; Warframe.

Our proposed pick: Crimson Desert. Pearl Abyss turned complaints and requests into changes people could use, quickly and repeatedly. Its first-week patch explicitly connected player feedback to new inventory storage and control improvements. Later updates added difficulty settings, boss rematches, expanded storage, and controller remapping. By August, the studio’s update recap counted seventeen patches and more than twenty features and content additions.

That is substantial support for a single-player game released this year. The strongest argument is the sequence: players identify a frustration, the team responds, and the next session becomes better. The November 13 patch shows that work continuing with progression fixes and improvements to boss retries.

The October release of Charting the Unknown adds to the year’s output, but our vote rests on responsive improvements to the existing game, not on treating an expansion as a substitute for support.

Warframe’s direct communication and No Man’s Sky’s sustained development make them serious rivals. Crimson Desert gets our proposed vote for the speed and substance of its response this year. Its GOTY omission is a separate argument.

🦊 Kiki: “This is why Crimson Desert deserves the argument. Players asked for practical changes, and the team kept shipping them. Storage, controls, rematches: things that affect what happens when somebody sits down to play, rather than what happens when a social account posts a heart emoji.

“I am not handing out a medal for fixing one broken door. The sustained response is the point. Keep listening after the launch money arrives. Keep improving the game people already bought. A single-player adventure should not become an archaeological site the moment the marketing team moves on to the next trailer.”

🍪 Chip: Chip floats past a stack of unanswered request cards and places completed patch notes beside the matching complaints.

Best Independent Game

Nominees: Big Walk; Cairn; Denshattack!; Mewgenics; Mina the Hollower.

Close call: Mina the Hollower or Mewgenics. Mina makes the action-game case: the appeal of combat and the satisfaction of mastering a focused adventure. Mewgenics makes the systems-driven case, with players returning for the different situations its roguelite structure produces.

Being tired of roguelites is a legitimate personal preference, but it would be a weak reason to dismiss what Mewgenics achieves. Its nomination discussion includes enthusiastic supporters alongside people who prefer Mina or Big Walk. Our decision is whether to put the stronger weight on Mina’s action or Mewgenics’ replayable systems. Cairn and Denshattack! complete a category that deserves more than leftovers from the GOTY discussion.

Best Debut Indie Game

Nominees: Dressmaker; Esoteric Ebb; Orbitals; Replaced; Silver Pines.

Our proposed pick: Dressmaker. Close alternative: Esoteric Ebb. Dressmaker’s appeal is more interesting than “a popular cozy game.” It commits to an audience and a creative fantasy that major releases too often treat as peripheral. We like that it does not dilute that identity to resemble whatever the largest releases are doing.

Esoteric Ebb answers with a writing-led RPG argument. The split appears even in Dressmaker’s nomination discussion, while Ebb’s supporters acknowledge Dressmaker’s breakout. Dressmaker leads our proposal; Ebb is the close alternative.

🦊 Kiki: “Dressmaker should not have to apologize for knowing who it wants to delight. We spend so much time asking for variety, then act surprised when somebody makes a game for an audience outside the usual queue of heavily armed men. Let a different fantasy have its turn.

“And Mina versus Mewgenics is a much better argument than ‘which one looks most expensive?’ Give me the combat that makes somebody learn one more encounter, or the systems that make somebody start one more run. Small studios do not need a sympathy trophy. They need us to take what they made seriously.”

🍪 Chip: Chip flies over a display of oversized prop swords and gives a tiny dress form and two indie-game boxes equal space on the shelf.

Best Mobile Game

Nominees: Arknights: Endfield; Monster Hunter Outlanders; Neverness to Everness; Pokémon Champions; Where Winds Meet.

Our proposed pick: Where Winds Meet. Its large-scale martial-arts adventure is the most compelling direction for our ballot. Arknights: Endfield and Neverness to Everness are the closest comparisons we want to discuss, for the final mobile vote.

The mobile category also raises a shortlist question: Where is Wuthering Waves? Its absence deserves discussion alongside the nominated Monster Hunter and Pokémon entries. Our proposal stays with Where Winds Meet.

Best VR / AR

Nominees: Forefront; Into the Radius 2; Little Nightmares VR: Altered Echoes; Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Empire City; Thief VR: Legacy of Shadow.

Our proposed pick: Forefront. The strongest argument is the multiplayer experience: players praise busy lobbies and the kind of VR shooter they had been waiting for. That support appears in its own community and in a broader PSVR comparison.

Into the Radius 2 has committed supporters who love its exploration, but its nomination thread also contains reports of disruptive co-op crashes. Those reports give Forefront the stronger case.

🦊 Kiki: “Forefront’s players keep bringing up full lobbies. That matters. A multiplayer game can have a wonderful feature list and still give you an evening of staring at a matchmaking screen. The people showing up, staying, and having a good time are part of the achievement.

“Into the Radius has players who clearly love exploring it, too. But if co-op keeps throwing somebody out, that is part of their evening whether the underlying game is brilliant or not. My friend and I arranged time to play together. We did not arrange a joint troubleshooting seminar with optional monsters.”

🍪 Chip: Chip floats beside two connected headsets, catches one cable before it comes loose, and holds it firmly in place.

Best Action Game

Nominees: Ace Combat 8: Wings of Theve; Gears of War: E-Day; Onimusha: Way of the Sword; Phantom Blade Zero; Saros.

Our pick: Phantom Blade Zero. Its combat is central to why we consider it a serious GOTY contender. The absence of Crimson Desert and Nioh 3 also deserves an argument; this was a crowded action year, not a year with only five worthwhile combat systems. The technical problems still matter, but a combat-focused category makes its strengths particularly relevant. Ace Combat, Gears, Onimusha, and Saros give it substantial competition in a strong action category.

Best Action / Adventure

Nominees: 007 First Light; Control Resonant; Grand Theft Auto VI; Pragmata; Resident Evil Requiem; The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time.

Our pick: Control Resonant. Crimson Desert’s absence is frustrating here too: its exploration and combat give it a clear argument for an action-adventure shortlist. Among the games actually nominated, Control’s balance works in its favor. We would consider Pragmata separately for what it brings to the category, while the weaknesses we identified in 007, Requiem, and Ocarina continue to affect our choices.

Best Role Playing

Nominees: Final Fantasy Resonance; Fire Emblem Fortune’s Weave; Monster Hunter Stories 3: Twisted Reflection; The Blood of Dawnwalker; Trails in the Sky 2nd Chapter.

Our proposed pick: The Blood of Dawnwalker. Its thirty-day-and-night framework makes deciding how to spend time part of the role-playing. The developers describe quests without a rigid main-versus-side hierarchy and different possibilities by day and night. Players making its RPG case praise the writing, side content, and darker tone.

We are huge Fire Emblem fans, and we played Fortune’s Weave. The core strengths of the series are still enjoyable, but the new additions left us underwhelmed and the story is not among its best. For us, it is an 8/10. We disagree with the perfect-score assessments; our affection for the series does not make it our automatic RPG winner.

The same player discussion includes strong alternatives: Trails for its story and battle system, along with supporters of Fire Emblem and Final Fantasy Resonance. Dawnwalker remains our proposed choice, with Trails the strongest alternative to discuss. Fire Emblem stays in the comparison, but our own experience gives us reasons to look beyond it.

🦊 Kiki: “I love Fire Emblem. That is precisely why I can say this one is an eight. The familiar strengths are enjoyable, the additions did not excite us enough, and the story can do better. Being a fan does not require pretending every new release is the best thing the series has ever done.

“Those perfect scores do not change what we thought of it. I want the next game to improve the parts that disappointed us, and that becomes a difficult conversation if we greet everything with a ten and a standing ovation. The franchise already has our affection. It can still earn a better report card.”

🍪 Chip: Chip hovers beside a Fire Emblem banner, sticks a small heart to it, and leaves the scorecard at eight.

Best Fighting

Nominees: 2XKO; Avatar Legends: The Fighting Game; Invincible VS; Marvel Tōkon: Fighting Souls; My Hero Academia: All’s Justice.

Close call: Avatar Legends for our vote; Marvel Tōkon as the likely winner. The fighting-game community discussion repeatedly separates those two positions. Players praise how enjoyable Avatar is to play and watch while expecting Tōkon to win. Other comments raise Avatar’s launch shortcomings and Tōkon’s PC problems.

That gives us a real choice, rather than simply selecting the largest franchise. Avatar has the more persuasive player argument in the discussion we reviewed; the launch-state criticism still deserves weight.

Best Family

Nominees: Big Walk; Lego Batman: Legacy of the Dark Knight; Nintendo Switch Sports Resort; Pokémon Pokopia; Yoshi and the Mysterious Book.

Decision for review: Best Family. Big Walk brings the strongest shared-play argument from the discussions we reviewed. Nintendo Switch Sports Resort is the alternative if we want to prioritize immediate, approachable group play. Pokémon Pokopia, Yoshi, and Lego Batman offer different family experiences. Which kind of family play should lead our vote?

Best Sim / Strategy

Nominees: Mewgenics; Planet Zoo 2; Pokémon Pokopia; Slay the Spire 2; Star Wars Zero Company.

Our proposed pick: Mewgenics. Close alternative: Slay the Spire 2. The choice is between different kinds of planning. Mewgenics gives us the stronger argument for longer-term decisions, while Slay the Spire 2 emphasizes adjusting to the cards and opportunities a run gives us. That makes Mewgenics our proposal here even while the indie category remains a closer comparison with Mina.

Planet Zoo 2 and Pokémon Pokopia reward different management instincts; Star Wars Zero Company adds another tactical contender. Slay the Spire 2 is the one we should discuss before locking Mewgenics in.

Best Sports / Racing

Nominees: EA Sports FC 27; Forza Horizon 6; Nintendo Switch Sports Resort; Screamer; Star Wars: Galactic Racer.

Close call: Star Wars: Galactic Racer or Forza Horizon 6. Galactic Racer now has the stronger argument for our vote. Players praise its return to energetic arcade racing and its fresh combination of systems; the criticism of Forza is that the familiar formula has become too familiar. Those comparisons appear in Forza’s own nomination thread as well as the general awards discussion.

Forza still has supporters who see it as the stronger complete racer. Screamer also deserves credit in the discussion, particularly from players who value its split-screen experience. We should choose between Forza’s established strengths and Galactic Racer’s fresher approach, rather than defaulting to Forza.

Best Multiplayer

Nominees: Big Walk; Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 4; Gears of War: E-Day; Marathon; Meccha Chameleon; Orbitals.

Close call: Big Walk or Meccha Chameleon. Big Walk’s strongest player argument is how enjoyable it is with friends and strangers. Even in another nominee’s community, players bring it up as a likely winner, while Marathon supporters defend the game they keep returning to. Meccha Chameleon has already taken the multiplayer award at the Golden Joysticks.

That makes these smaller games serious contenders against Call of Duty, Gears, and Marathon. Orbitals completes a shortlist where cooperation has as much right to the trophy as competition.

Marathon is the nomination we question. At the time of writing, SteamDB showed a 24-hour peak of 2,793 concurrent Steam players, against its all-time peak of 88,337. These are Steam figures, not the total across platforms. Bungie itself acknowledged that Marathon fell short of its audience expectations and announced plans to broaden the experience. In the same update, it committed to restoring vaulted Destiny 2 content and credited the Destiny community’s response with helping change its direction.

🦊 Kiki: “What the fuck is Marathon doing here? Best Multiplayer, while Bungie is explaining why it failed to attract the audience it wanted and how it needs to change? I am supposed to look at that Steam collapse and nod politely while somebody prepares the nomination graphic?

“Yes, a smaller community can love a great game. But this is not some tiny project quietly finding its people. Bungie is trying to win back trust, rework Marathon, and restore the Destiny content players have been demanding. Good. Do that work. I am much more interested in the players getting a better evening than the studio getting a nicer slide for its next presentation.

“This nomination makes me question what the jury is rewarding. The Bungie name does not make the case for them. Show me why this belongs among the year’s best multiplayer experiences, because a recovery plan and a recognizable logo are not doing it for me. Big Walk and Meccha Chameleon are where I would rather put this vote.”

🍪 Chip: Chip hovers beside Marathon’s nomination card, checks the Steam chart twice, then silently slides the tiny trophy toward Big Walk and Meccha Chameleon.

Best Adaptation

Nominees: Cyberpunk: Edgerunners 2; Fallout (Season 2); Mortal Kombat II; Resident Evil; The Super Mario Galaxy Movie.

Close call: The Super Mario Galaxy Movie, Cyberpunk: Edgerunners 2, or Fallout Season 2. Mario’s worldwide impact belongs in this discussion. The film earned approximately US$1.01 billion worldwide, including US$583 million outside North America. Universal also reported an A− CinemaScore and a 90% Rotten Tomatoes audience score at launch. That is a substantial international audience and a strong early response, not just a familiar name on the poster.

Bringing a game world to that many moviegoers is a real achievement for an adaptation. Mario deserves serious consideration alongside Edgerunners and Fallout, rather than a passing mention. The box office does not decide our vote by itself, but we cannot ignore that reach. Our final choice among the three remains open.

Resident Evil is a decent horror movie, but a bad Resident Evil movie. Those are different judgments, and this award is for adaptation. It would not get our vote here.

Best User Creation

Nominees: A Dream of Silence: Revamped, for Baldur’s Gate 3; Create Aeronautics, for Minecraft; Nopixel V, for Grand Theft Auto Online; Star Wars Droid Tycoon, for Fortnite; TTK, for Roblox.

Close call: Create Aeronautics or Nopixel V. Nopixel was our first proposal, but the case for Create Aeronautics deserves more attention. Players describe how its physics-based airships and the wider Create ecosystem change what they can build and do in Minecraft. That is a concrete creative achievement to put against Nopixel’s role-playing possibilities.

A Dream of Silence, Star Wars Droid Tycoon, and TTK complete the shortlist. For our ballot, the interesting decision is building new physical possibilities versus building a space for shared role-play.

🦊 Kiki: “Create Aeronautics makes a wonderful case for what player-made work can add. Give people new ways to build, move, and experiment, and suddenly a familiar game contains possibilities its players did not have before. That is an achievement worth putting on a stage.

“Nopixel comes at it from another direction: people making stories together. That comparison is much more interesting than deciding which parent game has the biggest logo. And when the winner arrives, put the actual creators’ names where people can see them. The platform has had quite enough opportunities to introduce itself.”

🍪 Chip: Chip flies beneath an enormous game logo and pulls a small creators’ name card forward until it is visible.

Content Creator of the Year

Nominees: CDawg; Cellbit; iShowSpeed; LilSimsie; OhnePixel.

Close call: iShowSpeed or CDawg. Speed’s ability to reach beyond a narrow gaming audience is the argument behind the initial proposal, but CDawg’s supporters make a case based on his range of gaming content and charitable work rather than reach alone. The discussion around his nomination also acknowledges LilSimsie and Cellbit as strong alternatives.

We should settle whether our vote rewards broad audience reach or a more gaming-centered contribution. OhnePixel belongs in that conversation too; this category covers several very different communities.

Best Esports Athlete

Nominees: Chovy, Gen.G; Donk, Team Spirit; Erde, LOUD; Yatoro, Team Spirit; ZywOo, Team Vitality.

No pick. We do not follow esports, and these nominees are unfamiliar to us. We are not going to choose a name just to fill the ballot. From our side of gaming, the scene feels like a separate niche, with its own stars and stories that rarely reach us.

Best Esports Game

Nominees: Counter-Strike 2; Dota 2; League of Legends; Mobile Legends: Bang Bang; Valorant.

Proposal for discussion: Counter-Strike 2. The question is which competitive scene delivered the strongest year, including the tournaments and the experience for its players.

Best Esports Team

Nominees: Gen.G, League of Legends; LOUD, Valorant; Team Falcons, Counter-Strike 2; Team Falcons, Rocket League; Team Spirit, Dota 2; Team Vitality, Counter-Strike 2.

No pick here either. We do not follow these teams closely enough to back one. The two Team Falcons entries represent different squads, in Counter-Strike 2 and Rocket League.

We think esports needs to reconnect with the wider gaming audience. Give people outside the scene a reason to care about the players, rivalries, and stakes instead of assuming we already know them. That is our frustration as outsiders, not a claim that nobody watches: Worlds 2026 reached 3.98 million peak viewers, despite falling 41% from the previous year, while English, French, Portuguese, and Spanish broadcasts gained watch time. The audience is international; it just is not reaching us.

🦊 Kiki: “Speed reaching people far outside a narrow gaming audience is a real argument. CDawg’s supporters care about the games, the charity work, and the relationship with their community. Those are different reasons to value a creator, and I would rather hear them than watch everybody compare follower counts until the largest number wins.

“With esports, you have lost me. I do not know these players well enough to cheer for one, and flashing their names beside a trophy does not suddenly give me a favorite. Show me the rivalry, the comeback, the reason this match mattered. I already love games. Getting me interested should not require arriving with three seasons of homework.”

🍪 Chip: Chip floats between the two Team Falcons cards and adds a tiny game icon to each before arranging the individual player portraits beneath them.

Most Anticipated Game

Nominees: Fable; Final Fantasy VII Revelation; God of War Laufey; Resident Evil Veronica; The Witcher 4.

Our proposed pick: The Witcher 4, with Final Fantasy VII Revelation the closest alternative. The appeal is the prospect of returning to that world with a new central story, backed by the affection that The Witcher 3 still commands. Final Fantasy VII brings its own enormous investment in seeing that ongoing remake project through. Resident Evil Veronica is an especially interesting discussion for us because we want remakes to attempt meaningful reinvention. Fable, Final Fantasy VII, God of War, and The Witcher all raise the same larger question: what will this new entry do beyond giving us familiar names again?

Players’ Voice

The separate Players’ Voice ballot shows its first round opening November 30, with thirty nominees and votes for ten. The later rounds narrow the field to ten, then five. No first-round nominee list was visible when we checked, so that ballot follows separately.

This will be worth watching alongside the main awards. We also will not treat a fan-voted result as a command to change our own opinion. Agreement is enjoyable. Disagreement is half the reason to talk about games in the first place.

🦊 Kiki: “Tell me why your choice deserves it. Give me the mechanic, the scene, the music, the change that made you come back. I can have a much better argument with that than with somebody announcing that every person who enjoyed a different game is an idiot.

“And if your favorite loses, you are still allowed to enjoy it tomorrow. Geoff is not coming round to delete the save. The trophy is an excuse to celebrate and argue about the work, not an eviction notice for everybody else’s taste. Keep the enthusiasm. Perhaps leave the imaginary courtroom at home.”

🍪 Chip: Chip hovers over an untouched save file, places a tiny protective cookie beside it, and lets the televised trophy ceremony continue in the background.

Control Resonant remains our strongest balanced GOTY contender, with Phantom Blade Zero a serious challenger. Crimson Desert is still the game we would have added to that shortlist.

Which choices would you change, and where would you make the strongest case for a game we have left open?

⚙️ Stay curious like a voter who follows the unfamiliar nominee instead of scrolling past it.

⚙️ Keep arguing for great games like Kiki defending the Ace Combat playlist.

⚙️ And remember: a golden trophy is lovely, but it still cannot patch a bad ending.

🦊 Kiki · 🍪 Chip · ⭐ Byte · 🦁 Leo

Tips, leaks, and suspiciously rehearsed acceptance speeches: contact us here!

Weekly gaming news bites

Your Sunday Cookie Box.

Five handpicked Game Cookies stories in one free Sunday email.

Kiki offers a cookie-sealed newsletter envelope while Chip bounces beside a stack of letters in a sunlit room.
A fresh delivery from Kiki and Chip.

Don’t miss any cookie!

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Stay in the loop

Follow Game Cookies on social.

Daily bites on the platforms you already scroll. Pick your poison.

Share this story